S01:E01 - Carole Clement
The Ace of Hearts from Florida. A beloved mother and grandmother is found stabbed in her seaside home. Suspicion falls on her ex but his alibi holds, and the case takes a turn.
S01:E02 - Susan “Susie” Poupart
The 7 of Spades from Wisconsin. When 29-year-old Susie left a house party on her reservation with younger men, she never made it home. Six months later, her remains were found.
S01:E03 - Sharon Glover
The 6 of Spades from Louisiana. After Sharon Glover was killed in 1993, her family suspected someone close. Now, detectives say another suspect may have been overlooked.
S01:E04 - Jefferson "Jeff" West
The King of Diamonds from Mississippi. On a summer day in 2018, Jeff West walked into the woods near his mother’s home and never came back.
S01:E05 - Roger “Unkle Rog” McCall
The 2 of Spades from New York. After surviving cancer, longtime DJ “Unkle Rog” was shot in 2003. A potential witness now suggests a more personal motive.
S01:E06 - Lawrence Riegel
The 5 of Spades from Washington. Phone records and strange theories shaped the search for Lawrence in 2010. Police honed in on two people but still lack what they need.
S01:E07 - Luther Meshell
The 9 of Hearts from Louisiana. In 1991, Luther was found dead in his home. Police first believed he knew his killer until a pattern began to take shape.
S01:E08 - Andrew Moore
The 6 of Clubs from California. Andy Moore was murdered in his apartment in 2000. Missing weapons, odd clues, and a strange discovery have puzzled detectives for decades.
S01:E09 - George Kirkland, Asia Norman, and Lindsay Foster Hurr
The 2 of Clubs from Mississippi. Three people were killed in a Mississippi home in 2019, and no one heard a thing. More than five years later, the case remains tangled in rumors.
S01:E10 - Gwendel Greenblatt
The 6 of Diamonds from Florida. On the phone and steps from home, Gwen should have been safe. But something was waiting just behind her apartment door.
S01:E11 - Jodine Serrin
The 7 of Diamonds from California. Decades after meeting on a beach, Marisa learns the man she loved was responsible for Jodine Serrin’s brutal murder.
S01:E12 - The Leighton Avenue Killings
The 9, 10, Jack, and Queen of Hearts from New York. A Rochester house fire revealed four bound victims in a brutal scene. Nearly a decade later, the case remains unsolved.
S01:E13 - Ron Harnish
The 7 of Clubs from California. Twenty-two-year-old Ron Harnish was murdered in 2006. Years later, police have a suspect but building the case has been a challenge.
S01:E14 - Patricia Allen
The Queen of Hearts from Washington. In 1995, Patricia Allen was killed by a single, precise stab while she slept. What followed became one of Yakima’s most baffling cases.
S01:E15 - Gregory Fickess
The Jack of Diamonds from New York. A fatal attack in 1993 left Gregory Fickess dead. Years later, a witness’s sudden death added a chilling layer to the case.