The Deck
S03:E14 - Norris Evans
The Jack of Spades from New York. A 1975 murder left Norris Evans dead and her children upstairs. Decades later, they’re searching for answers.
S03:E13 - Darnell Smith
The 5 of Diamonds from California. A pastor’s son with big plans was killed at 20. Years later, new reporting may have uncovered the key to solving his case.
S03:E12 - Thomas Mather
The 7 of Diamonds from Iowa. Thomas Mather’s murder remains a town’s only unsolved case. Evidence points in different directions and the question remains: did she do it?
S03:E11 - Jonathan Garcia-Valladares
The 7 of Diamonds from Arizona. In 2010, 13-year-old Jonathan Garcia-Valladares set out for a run and never came home. Fifteen years later, his case remains unsolved.
S03:E10 - Tyra Garcia
The Queen of Hearts from California. A quick trip in 1985 ended in tragedy when 15-year-old Tyra Garcia was found murdered. Today, new eyes are on long-overlooked suspects.
S03:E09 - Agustin Chacon and Marshall McCarthy
The King of Clubs and 5 of Hearts from Texas. Two men were killed in the same Odessa neighborhood on the same night in 1982. More than 40 years later, the cases remain unsolved.
S03:E08 - Charles "Chuck" McGraw
The 10 of Spades from Indiana. A man known for bold suits and big money was killed, leaving behind a complicated life investigators are still trying to untangle.
S03:E07 - Paris Matthews
The 6 of Hearts from Florida. In 2013, Paris Matthews answered a knock at his door and was shot moments later. Years of rumors and leads haven’t revealed his killer.
S03:E06 - Maria “Mary Faye” Mendez
The Wild Card from Texas. Mary Faye Mendez left her home in 1985 and disappeared. Years later, a detective’s fresh look is uncovering long-buried clues.
S03:E05 - Kyle Seidel
The 5 of Diamonds from Connecticut. Kyle Seidel left home for takeout in 2012 and never returned. Investigators believe they know who was involved but still don’t know why.
S03:E04 - Karen Streed
The 4 of Spades from Iowa. In 1971, Karen disappeared while hitchhiking. Was she the victim of a passing predator or something closer to home?
S03:E03 - Theresa Dusevitch
The Queen of Diamonds from Florida. For decades, Theresa Dusevitch’s case was tied to another 1973 murder until DNA proved otherwise. Now, investigators are taking a fresh look.
S03:E02 - Shad Gandy Kaydea
The 2 of Spades from Rhode Island. A cemetery fire revealed the body of Shad Gandy Kaydea. Years later, investigators are still chasing a suspect whose story doesn’t add up.
S03:E01 - Margaret Reimann
The Queen of Spades from California. When Margaret Reimann was killed in 1986, fingers pointed at family. Today, new DNA is sending investigators in a new direction.