The Deck
S04:E01 - Tangie Sims
T04:C12 - S04:E12 - Terry and Alan Westerfield
The King of Diamonds from North Carolina. In 1964, two children were dropped off at the movies and never came home. Sixty years later, their disappearance remains a mystery.
T04:C11 - S04:E11 - Lindsay Wells
The King of Diamonds from California. In 1999, Lindsay Wells vanished from Simi Valley. Sightings and leads followed, but none that led to answers
T04:C10 - S04:E10 - Jason Vesper
The 10 of Diamonds from Nebraska. A 2008 night ended with Jason Vesper murdered outside his home. Surveillance shows almost everything, except the moment that matters most.
T04:C09 - S04:E09 - Janet Couture
The Jack of Diamonds from Connecticut. Janet Couture’s 1973 murder went unsolved for decades until 2025, when a longtime suspect was finally arrested.
T04:C08 - S04:E08 - Mason Worthington
The Wild Card from Virginia. A 20-year-old was shot in his Williamsburg home in 2018. Detectives believe someone out there knows what happened.
T04:C07 - S04:E07 - Jeffrey Dale Nichols
The 6 of Diamonds from Utah. Jeffrey Nichols vanished after a meeting in 2004. Conflicting stories and a hidden clue are raising new questions decades later.
T04:C06 - S04:E06 - Kenneth “Kenny” Floyd
The Wild Card from Colorado. In 1995, Kenny Floyd’s killer left behind blood and a DNA trail to the Caribbean. Years later, investigators are still working to name him.
T04:C05 - S04:E05 - Lois West
The Ace of Hearts from Virginia. A vacant house in 1986 held a shocking discovery: a woman in a bathtub and a trail of strange clues investigators are still working to solve.
T04:C04 - S04:E04 - Daphne Hope
The 8 of Spades from Colorado. Daphne Hope vanished in 2001, and her case went cold. Decades later, theories swirl but answers are still missing.
T04:C03 - S04:E03 - Ronda Taylor and Bonnie Ryther
The King of Clubs and 9 of Diamonds from Florida. One man is serving life for a 1989 murder, but his confessions suggest more victims. Now, a detective is trying to prove the truth.
T04:C02 - S04:E02 - Rose Burkert and Roger Atkison
The 9 of Diamonds from Iowa. In 1980, Rose and Roger were found murdered in a hotel room. Nearly 50 years later, an exclusive update could finally solve the case.
T04:C01 - S04:E01 - Tangie Sims
The 9 of Diamonds from Colorado. Tangie Sims’ 1996 murder went cold after leads ran dry. Decades later, new DNA tools finally pointed investigators in the right direction.