There was a time when having a crush in a YA movie was simply not enough. Your crush needed a secret. Preferably supernatural. Their family needed several generations of lore. Somebody had to warn you to stay away. You would not stay away. Obviously.
Beautiful Creatures understood the assignment. Ethan Wate is desperate for something interesting to happen in his small South Carolina town when Lena Duchannes arrives carrying exactly the kind of mystery he probably should've left alone. She's a Caster approaching her 16th birthday, when she'll be claimed for either Light or Dark, and getting close to Ethan makes an already complicated supernatural future even messier.
But the reason to revisit Beautiful Creatures isn't simply finding out which side claims Lena. It's watching a movie go all in on the kind of YA sincerity that once made supernatural romance an entire cultural event. The feelings are enormous. The family history goes back generations. A teenage crush can interfere with destiny itself. Nobody is embarrassed about any of it.
Tubi's The YA Edit has plenty more big feelings waiting once you're ready to make your watchlist unnecessarily complicated. Once Gatlin has delivered enough supernatural drama, 10 of the best YA movies on Tubi can introduce your watchlist to several completely different kinds of teenage chaos.
Your crush has baggage. Lena's has generations of it.