The Deck
S05:E07 - Kelsie Schelling
S05:E08 - Kevin Nguyen
The 10 of Spades from Indiana. Kevin Nguyen vanished after a night out in Fort Wayne in 2018. Years later, rumors, tips, and unanswered questions still surround his disappearance.
S05:E07 - Kelsie Schelling
The 10 of Spades from Colorado. Pregnant 21-year-old Kelsie Schelling disappeared in 2013. More than a decade later, her body remains missing despite a murder conviction.
S05:E06 - Milagros Nieves
The 3 of Clubs from Connecticut. Milagros Nieves was killed in a brutal attack that haunted her family for years. Now, new findings are reshaping the case.
S05:E05 - Clarence and Marjorie Paulson
The 2 of Clubs from Minnesota. A father and daughter disappeared from their Minnesota home in 1984, leaving behind their belongings and few clues. Six years later, the mystery took a dark turn.
S05:E04 - Edwin "Eddie" Heath Sr.
The King of Hearts from Delaware. Eddie Heath was shot and killed steps from his home in 2014. More than a decade later, detectives still don't know who pulled the trigger or why.
S05:E03 - Angelica Sandoval
The 3 of Hearts from Colorado. Angelica Sandoval seemed to disappear mid-errand in 2011. Investigators are still sorting through suspects, rumors, and unanswered questions.
S05:E02 - Jimmy "Jamie" Riddle
The 9 of Diamonds from North Carolina. In 1991, Jimmy “Jamie” Riddle was found dead in a Fayetteville lake. New investigators are hoping DNA can finally provide answers.
S05:E01 - Nefertiri "Neffie" Trader
The Queen of Hearts from Delaware. Nefertiri “Neffie” Trader was abducted from outside her home in 2014. Despite a witness, her disappearance remains unsolved.